Why New Year’s Resolutions Don’t Work (And Why They’re Setting You Up to Fail)
- cm1619
- Dec 29, 2025
- 3 min read
Every January, millions of people make New Year’s resolutions with genuine hope and motivation. Eat healthier. Exercise more. Stop procrastinating. Reduce anxiety. Finally feel happier.
And yet… by mid-January, most resolutions have already fallen away.
If that sounds familiar, here’s the important truth:
NEW YEARS RESOLUTIONS DON'T WORK!
In this blog, we’ll explore why New Year’s resolutions don’t work, how they can damage your confidence and self-trust, and what actually creates real, lasting change instead.
The Statistics Behind New Year’s Resolutions
Research consistently shows that around 80% of New Year’s resolutions fail by February. Not because people are lazy or unmotivated — but because resolutions are built on flawed assumptions about how change actually happens.
Most resolutions focus on what you want to change, without addressing why you behave the way you do in the first place.
And that’s where things start to unravel.
1. New Year’s Resolutions Are Built on Self-Criticism
At their core, most resolutions begin with an unspoken belief:
“Something about me isn’t good enough and needs fixing.”
“Eat better” often really means I don't like my body.“Be more confident” often means I’m not good enough as I am.“Stop feeling anxious” often means there’s something wrong with me.
When change is driven by self-criticism, your nervous system goes into threat mode. And a threatened nervous system doesn’t change — it protects.
This is why resolutions often trigger:
Anxiety
Guilt
All-or-nothing thinking
Feelings of shame when you ‘slip up’
So, instead of motivating you, resolutions often reinforce the very patterns you’re trying to change.
2. They Ignore Your Nervous System (And Your Emotions)
You can’t mindset your way out of anxiety, stress, or deeply ingrained habits.
Many resolutions assume that willpower alone is enough. But willpower lives in the logical brain — while habits, anxiety, and emotional responses live in the nervous system and subconscious mind.
If your body associates change with:
Fear
Overwhelm
Past failure
Emotional discomfort
…it will resist, no matter how badly you want to change.
This is why you may feel motivated one day and completely stuck the next. It’s not inconsistency — it’s biology.
3. Resolutions Create Unrealistic Pressure
“New year, new you” sounds inspiring — but it’s also incredibly harsh.
It suggests:
You must change now
You must change everything
And if you don’t, you’ve wasted another year
That pressure activates stress hormones like cortisol, which actually reduce motivation, focus, and emotional regulation.
When change feels overwhelming, the brain looks for relief — and relief often comes from old coping patterns, not new habits.
So you abandon the resolution… and blame yourself.
4. They Focus on Outcomes, Not Identity or Safety
Most resolutions are outcome-based:
Lose 10 pounds
Earn more money
Stop feeling anxious
But sustainable change happens when you feel safe enough to become someone new, not when you force yourself toward a goal.
If your identity still believes:
I’m not disciplined
I always mess things up
Change never lasts for me
…your subconscious will keep proving those beliefs right.
This isn’t self-sabotage — it’s self-protection.
5. Resolutions Don’t Teach You How to Be Kind to Yourself
One missed workout.One anxious day.One emotional setback.
And suddenly the resolution feels ‘ruined’.
Resolutions rarely include:
Self-compassion
Emotional flexibility
Gentle recalibration
Instead, they promote perfectionism.
But real change requires kindness, not punishment. People who practice self-compassion are actually more likely to stay consistent, resilient, and motivated over time.
So… What Does Work Instead?
If resolutions don’t work, what does?
1. Choose Regulation Over Resolution
Instead of asking “What should I change?” ask:
“What helps me feel calmer, safer, and more supported?”
A regulated nervous system creates natural motivation.
2. Focus on Small, Identity-Based Shifts
Think:
“I grow when I'm kind to myself.”
“I’m stronger when I support my anxiety, instead of fighting it.”
Tiny, consistent shifts rewire beliefs far more effectively than big declarations.
3. Work With Your Subconscious, Not Against It
Lasting change happens when you address:
Emotional patterns
Core beliefs
Past experiences stored in the body
This is where approaches like EFT, hypnotherapy, and trauma certified coaching create transformation — without force.
A New Way to Start the Year
You don’t need another resolution and you don't need to wait for a certain date to make a start.
You need:
Understanding, not pressure
Support, not self-criticism
Safety, not force
This year, instead of asking “How can I finally fix myself?”… try asking:
“How can I support myself in a way that actually lasts?”
Because real change doesn’t come from January promises.
It comes from learning how to work with yourself — not against yourself.
If anxiety, self-criticism, or emotional overwhelm are part of why change feels so hard, support can make all the difference.
If you'd like to learn more about how I can support you to make the changes you are longing for, please book a free consultation and take the first step.
Chris.
Comments